---
title: Duo or Don't?
date: 2026-10-22
date_published: 2026-10-22
status: published
tags:
  - apple
  - iphone
summary: "Why Thom picked the iPhone 18 Pro Max over the Duo: a polished prototype isn't what you want as a primary working device."
---

Since this year was my time to upgrade my phone (I skipped several generations), I had to make a decision: iPhone 18, iPhone 18 Max, or iPhone Duo? 

My answer was Max. I'm not sure I need the 50% faster CPU or 210% faster GPUs, though like more pixels, I'll take more computing horsepower when I can get it. The extra battery life will be useful when I'm in Africa.

Indeed, the choice between the 18 Pro and the 18 Pro Max came down to that (plus the larger screen), though this is at the expense of size and weight.

But why not the Duo? After all, I travel with an iPad Mini, and a Duo might have allowed me to carry one device (the Duo) instead of two (an iPhone and iPad)?

As a lot of folk are discovering, the "phone" form factor for a Duo is the issue, as well as how the user interface changes on the Duo (fingerprint versus face ID, odd shape for mounting on camera, moving dock from bottom to side, etc.). 

I liked what John Gruber ([Daring Fireball](https://daringfireball.net/)) wrote about the Duo: *"The very nature of the iPhone Duo raises numerous obvious questions about what it’s like to use...Clearly, the point of a Duo review is to answer these questions, which really boil down to one question: How did Apple solve these problems? The answer is: They didn’t."*

If the original iPhone had been the size/shape of the Duo when folded, not only would have the problems John (and others) identified have been solved, but we'd all be used to that shape and UX by now. If the iPad Mini allowed (or forced) the dock on the right in the horizontal orientation, we'd all be used to that by now. 

It's bad enough that Apple has changed and moved critical icons around a lot over the course of iOS, but putting the Back icon (<) anywhere other than upper left of screen is just another cognitive dissonance. Worse still, that icon *does* go to the upper left when you multitask windows on the unfolded pad in the horizontal orientation.

Apple has been violating what used to be an enforced guideline for some time now with operating system updates: moving things from their user-known position is a no-no. Couple that with undiscoverable actions (hidden swipes and touches) and you're just asking for hurting user comfort and productivity. 

It's not just me that has this problem, and it's not just Apple creating it. I have this problem with my 92-year-old mom all the time: a command/icon moves/changes and she's not sure where it went or what to do. But when you couple that with the fact that Amazon, Google, Meta, and virtually every app developer on the planet is 100% inconsistent with command visibility and placement between versions, the view on your LCD just seems like chaos all the time. That Apple is generating that problem so much on the Duo is evidence that they didn't think through their UI guidelines well enough to start with.

Gruber's conclusion to his review was: *"It’s been a lot of fun trying the Duo out for a week, but it feels like I’ve gotten to use an extraordinarily polished prototype — not a finished product that I’d want to buy and carry."* That seems right to me. 

While I love playing with prototypes, they're not what I want to use for my primary working devices. So no Duo for me, a Max it was.